Filed Under Native Americans

Santa Fe Plaza and Religious Repression

Cracks in the Spanish Walls

In 1775, Governor Juan Francisco Treviño’s first year in office, he ordered the arrest of forty-seven Puebloan religious leaders and had them stand trial for witchcraft. Santa Fe was shortly surrounded by a force of angry and armed Puebloan men, forcing the governor to release the Pueblo religious leaders. Among those released was a shaman from Ohkay Owingeh Pueblo named Popé, who later became the architect of the Pueblo Revolt of 1680.

The Santa Fe Plaza is a traditional Spanish colonial style city square built in 1610 by the founders of Santa Fe under the orders of Don Pedro de Peralta, the second governor of New Mexico. Like other Spanish colonial plazas, the Santa Fe plaza served as the central hub of its city. It was flanked by the town church, the Palace of the Governors, and the houses of local notables.

The late 17th century was a period of drought, nomadic raids, and increased political repression for the Rio Grande Puebloan people. The Spanish Franciscan missionaries increasingly asserted their power over the New Mexican colony, culminating in a showdown with the provincial governor, Diego de Peñalosa. Governor Peñalosa arrived in New Mexico in 1661, and governed until ousted by Franciscan political pressure in 1664. While in office, he banned forced Native American labor and worked to preserve Puebloan cultures. This led to excommunication by a local Catholic clergyman, which Peñalosa had arrested, triggering the series of events that led to his ouster and a Mexican Inquisition jail cell.

The following governor was also not to the local clergymen’s liking, so he was politically forced to retire as well, leading to installation of Governor Juan Francisco Treviño in 1675. He was dedicated to the supremacy of the Catholic faith and the eradication of Puebloan culture. In the same year that he came to power, he ordered Spanish troops to burn kivas and arrest forty-seven Puebloan religious authorities. He then commanded that they all be tried for witchcraft. After three men were executed and a third that was sentenced to death committed suicide, a large, armed group of Pueblo men surrounded the Santa Fe Plaza and demanded that the shamans be released from prison. With most of the Spanish troops of Santa Fe out fighting nomads, Governor Treviño was forced to release the men. One of the men released was determined to end the Spanish period in New Mexico and safeguard the religious traditions of Puebloan people. Popé, a religious leader from the pueblo Ohkay Owingeh, retreated to the safer and more distant Taos Pueblo after he was released, where he would hatch a plan to remove the Spaniards.

The Santa Fe Plaza continued being the center of city life after the reconquest of New Mexico by Don Diego de Vargas. To this day, it serves as the city center for many communal events like the annual Fiestas de Santa Fe. After the Civil War, the New Mexican government erected a monument in the middle of the plaza and dedicated to Union troops and Indian fighters. In 1974, an unidentified man chiseled out the word “savage,” which was used to describe indigenous people by the monument’s creators.

Images

Untitled This historical photo was taken in 1873 by American photographer Timothy H. O’Sullivan. It shows the San Miguel Chapel in Santa Fe, which was partially destroyed in the Pueblo Revolt. Built around 1610 by Tlaxcalan auxiliaries of conquistador Juan de Oñate, it is considered the oldest church in the United States. Source: O'Sullivan, Timothy H. "THE CHURCH OF SAN MIGUEL, THE OLDEST IN SANTA FE, NEW MEXICO." Digital Image. U.S. National Archives and Records Administration. Digitally published November 21, 2011.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:THE_CHURCH_OF_SAN_MIGUEL,_THE_OLDEST_IN_SANTA_FE,_NEW_MEXICO_-_NARA_-_524286.jpg
Creator: Timothy H. O'Sullivan.
Untitled This statue of Popé was finished in 2005 and unveiled at Ohkay Owingeh pueblo, Popé’s hometown. It is currently in Washington DC. Source: Kvaran, Einar Einarsson. "Popé." Digital Image. Wikimedia Commons. Digitally published May 22, 2005.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Pope-SR-03.jpg
Permission for use granted under the GNU Free Documentation License
Untitled This postcard from 1930-1945 shows a ground level view of the Santa Fe Plaza, with the Palace of the Governors visible in the background. It is likely that the forty-seven Pueblo spiritual leaders were held here. Source: Boston Public Library. "Historic plaza and "Rebel" monument, Santa Fe, New Mexico." Digital Image. Flickr. Digitally published February 11, 2011. 

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Historic_plaza_and_%27Rebel%27_monument,_Santa_Fe,_New_Mexico.jpg
Untitled This photo shows the monument that adorns the center of the Santa Fe plaza. The New Mexico territorial government erected it in 1866 to commemorate military victories against native people and Confederate forces. Creator: Photographed by Edgar I Bernal Sevilla.

Location

Metadata

Edgar I Bernal Sevilla, Northern Arizona University, “Santa Fe Plaza and Religious Repression,” Intermountain Histories, accessed April 15, 2024, https://www.intermountainhistories.org/items/show/326.